# Breach determination and four-factor risk assessment

HIPAA breach notification operations | Worked example with fictional data

Step: Determine whether the event is a reportable breach
Owner: Privacy officer + Breach counsel + Security forensics + Data owners
When: Start as soon as the event is contained; document the analysis before notification decisions and keep a dated supplemental review open as facts change

## Gather first
- PHI inventory
- Privacy Rule authorization analysis
- Encryption and key evidence
- Forensic findings
- HHS guidance
- Incident chronology

## How to prepare it
1. Identify the information, people, systems and recipients. Decide whether the data was PHI, whether it was unsecured under HHS guidance, and whether an impermissible acquisition, access, use or disclosure occurred.
2. Apply the breach presumption, then document each applicable exception or all four low-probability factors: nature and extent of PHI and re-identification risk; unauthorized recipient; actual acquisition or viewing; and mitigation.
3. For ransomware, evaluate what the malware did, what it could access, exfiltration evidence, propagation, integrity and availability. Record an evidence-based conclusion, dissenting views, approver and date for reopening if new facts emerge.

## Example

### Fictional factor 1
A claims export contains member names, dates of service and procedure codes. Privacy identifies the sensitivity and explains the practical re-identification risk.

### Fictional factor 2
Forensics determines whether the recipient was an authorized cloud subcontractor, an unknown attacker or a person who returned the material without reading it.

### Fictional factor 3
The team distinguishes a confirmed file open from an unverified access log and states what the logs can and cannot prove.

### Fictional factor 4
The file is recovered and access revoked, but the memo separately evaluates whether copies or credentials remain with the recipient.

## Review
A reviewer can trace each legal conclusion to incident evidence and see why notice is required or why the firm can demonstrate a low probability of compromise.

## Handoff
Obtain Privacy and counsel sign-off before setting notice recipients or filing thresholds.

Official reference: HHS ransomware and HIPAA fact sheet
https://www.hhs.gov/hipaa/for-professionals/security/guidance/cybersecurity/ransomware-fact-sheet/index.html

Use the current rules and any prescribed forms for your engagement.
