COPRSETR WORKSHEET
Breach determination and four-factor risk assessment
HIPAA breach notification operations · Step 2 · Determine whether the event is a reportable breach- Who prepares it
- Privacy officer + Breach counsel + Security forensics + Data owners
- When to prepare it
- Start as soon as the event is contained; document the analysis before notification decisions and keep a dated supplemental review open as facts change
Worked example
This example uses fictional details. Use the same fields with evidence from your work.
- Fictional factor 1
- A claims export contains member names, dates of service and procedure codes. Privacy identifies the sensitivity and explains the practical re-identification risk.
- Fictional factor 2
- Forensics determines whether the recipient was an authorized cloud subcontractor, an unknown attacker or a person who returned the material without reading it.
- Fictional factor 3
- The team distinguishes a confirmed file open from an unverified access log and states what the logs can and cannot prove.
- Fictional factor 4
- The file is recovered and access revoked, but the memo separately evaluates whether copies or credentials remain with the recipient.
Gather first
- PHI inventory
- Privacy Rule authorization analysis
- Encryption and key evidence
- Forensic findings
- HHS guidance
- Incident chronology
How to prepare it
- Identify the information, people, systems and recipients. Decide whether the data was PHI, whether it was unsecured under HHS guidance, and whether an impermissible acquisition, access, use or disclosure occurred.
- Apply the breach presumption, then document each applicable exception or all four low-probability factors: nature and extent of PHI and re-identification risk; unauthorized recipient; actual acquisition or viewing; and mitigation.
- For ransomware, evaluate what the malware did, what it could access, exfiltration evidence, propagation, integrity and availability. Record an evidence-based conclusion, dissenting views, approver and date for reopening if new facts emerge.
Review
A reviewer can trace each legal conclusion to incident evidence and see why notice is required or why the firm can demonstrate a low probability of compromise.
Handoff
Obtain Privacy and counsel sign-off before setting notice recipients or filing thresholds.
Use the issuer’s current instructions and any required forms when you submit.
HHS ransomware and HIPAA fact sheet (opens in a new tab)